Tool Review: Mayhew Tools 3-pc Hammerless Set, No. 89021

April 13, 2023
Reviewed by John Baumgardt III, owner/operator of Baumgardt’s Auto Repair in Fillmore, Ind.

Content brought to you by PTEN. To subscribe, click here.

Q: How did the tool function as far as saving you time?

A: The hammerless set saved time trying to figure out how to get a punch and hammer into a space with limited room.

Q: How has using this tool impacted your shop’s profitability?

A: These increase profitability mainly by not having to repair or replace something after accidentally hitting it with a hammer while trying to hit a punch or chisel in a confined area.

Q: What kind of setup was involved before using the product?

A: Just remove the punch or chisel from the included pouch and you’re all set and ready to go.

Q: How easy was it to use?

A: Easy as can be. Hold one end of the punch or chisel in place and pull the other end against the spring tension and then release the end not being used.

Q: How was its packaging?

A: Nicely packaged in a pouch that is see-through from one side. It’s wide enough to hold six punches and still lay flat. There is a metal re-enforced hole for hanging and a button to keep the tools inside for when you toss it in a tool bag.

Q: What features did you like?

A: I liked their simple, easy-to-use design.

Q: Is there any way you could think to improve or add to this tool?

A: This is a super simple design and it’s great the way it is.

Q: What types of jobs/repairs did you use this tool for?

A: I used it to remove a couple roll pins and small bushings from transmission parts. This set includes a roll pin punch, hammer, center and prick punch, and a door pin punch. The door pin punch shines brightly when you need to remove the pin from the bottom hinge on the doors inside your shop or house.

Q: How does this tool compare to other tools you’ve used like it?

A: I’ve used the old hammer and punch method, and also automatic center punches. There is a huge advantage over the hammer and punch when there is limited space to work. There is even an advantage over the automatic center punch in some cases because you don’t have to put a bunch of pressure on the punch to make it operate.

Q: Is there anything you had questions or concerns about in regard to the tool?

A: Initially I wondered if there would be other sizes available, but after looking at the Mayhew Tools website I learned that there are quite a few other sizes. I will be purchasing them to add to my tool arsenal.

Q: On a scale of 1 to 10, how would you rate this tool overall? Why?

A: I would give this a 10. This is a super simple design that is easy to use and that will make many jobs easier. It really shines when there isn’t much room to hold a punch or chisel and fit a hammer and be able to swing it. You also have very good control of the pressure or force you are applying to the fastener. According to Mayhew, the tool can deliver 350 psi of force.  

About the Author

John Baumgardt III | Owner of Baumgardt’s Auto Repair

John Baumgardt III is the owner/operator of Baumgardt's Auto Repair in Fillmore, Indiana. He has been a professional auto tech for about 20 years. He attended the two-year Auto Mechanics program at Lancaster Vocational High School. Previously, Baumgardt worked at AAMCO Transmissions and earned about a dozen AAMCO certificates. He believes it’s important to provide an honest, quality service that people can depend on.

Sponsored Recommendations

AIRCAT Solutions - Small Ratchets With Enormous Power

Experience the power of AIRCAT's diverse ratchet selection. Each designed with a unique transmission gear for faster torque buildup and unbeatable performance. Their compact sizes...

Unmatched Power and Comfort: AIRCAT Grinders for Every Workspace

AIRCAT grinders deliver powerful performance with high RPM and efficient, quiet operation. Designed for comfort and control, they feature ergonomic handles, extended reach, and...

What Are the Advantages of Air Tools Over Cordless Tools?

Discover the advantages of air tools over cordless tools.

AIRCAT Tool Reviews: The Nitrocat 1056-XL Compact

Hear what senior autotechs have to say about the AIRCAT Nitrocat 1056-XL compact impact wrench. They’ll provide their reviews on tools they own and have been using every day on...

Voice Your Opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Vehicle Service Pros, create an account today!